News provided by CBC News – Link to full story and updates
Transgender activist says it’s time for all airlines to revise their gender categories
Sophia Harris · CBC News · Posted: Oct 20, 2019
In an effort to be more inclusive, Air Canada plans to drop gender references when welcoming passengers. That means no more onboard announcements opening with, “Ladies and gentlemen.”
The move follows a growing awareness and acceptance — including in the travel industry — that some individuals are non-binary, meaning they don’t identify as male or female.
However, Air Canada — along with most other airlines — still requires passengers to designate themselves as female or male when booking flights, something activists say needs to change.
“That just feels dishonest and also disrespectful that we’re forced to have to pick an identity that we don’t identify with,” said Gemma Hickey, a transgender activist in St. John’s who identifies as non-binary.
A few carriers, including Canada’s Porter Airlines, have added a gender-neutral booking option. Many others, including Air Canada, have pledged to do it. Hickey said Air Canada’s plan to revise its greeting is a good first step.
According to an employee memo issued last month, Air Canada said it will soon switch to the gender-free term “everyone” when greeting passengers.
“We want to ensure an inclusive space for everyone, including those who identify as gender X,” said the memo.
Since June, the federal government has allowed people who don’t identify as female or male to have an X printed on their passport, travel document, citizenship certificate or permanent resident card.
Most provinces now also offer the X gender option for government-issued ID cards such as driver’s licences.
Hickey was one of the first Canadians to get a passport with an X. But typically when booking a flight, that option still doesn’t exist.
“I’m not sure what the holdup is,” said Hickey, who emailed Canada’s major airlines in June 2018, lobbying for a non-binary gender category. “It doesn’t feel like I’m being respected as a person.”
However, Hickey had a positive experience recently when booking a flight with Porter. The airline adopted the X option, along with a gender-neutral onboard greeting, in the summer of 2018.
“It made me feel great to be able to choose [X] on an airline,” said Hickey.
Porter made the change “to better reflect the preferences of travellers” and to stay in step with gender categories offered on government documents, said spokesperson Brad Cicero in an email.
In March, U.S. airline United added the X, plus a U option, which stands for “undisclosed” gender.
“We are so proud to be the first U.S. airline to offer these inclusive booking options for our customers,” said United’s Chief Customer Officer Toby Enqvist in a statement.
In June, Air Italy became the first European airline to include the X gender category.
Back in Canada, WestJet says it’s making the necessary changes to its system to offer the X option.
The airline said that “due to the complexity of changes required,” it anticipates the category won’t be available until 2020.
WestJet is also re-evaluating its onboard greeting which refers to passengers as “ladies and gentlemen.”
“We are continuously assessing and evolving our practice and policies to maximize inclusiveness,” said spokesperson Morgan Bell in an email.
Air Canada didn’t respond to requests for comment. In February, it told The Canadian Press that it was looking into whether other governments and airline partners would recognize the X designation for international travellers.
“We are actively working on this, and we do intend to eventually offer a non-binary option to our customers,” said spokesperson Peter Fitzpatrick.
Will other countries accept an X passport?
On its website, the federal government warns there are no guarantees that when people travel, the countries they visit will accept an X gender identifier on their passport.
Hickey, who uses the pronoun “they,” said that, travelling with a passport marked with an X, they have visited four European countries plus Japan with no hassles.
In fact, Hickey said the gender designation actually helps cut the confusion when travelling, caused by appearing masculine but having a feminine-sounding first name, Gemma.
“My identity isn’t called into question anymore,” said Hickey. “People don’t ask me any questions about that because the X explains my name as well as how I present.”
Not all transgender activists are campaigning for an X option. Fran Forsberg of Saskatoon has two transgender children and wishes people could buy a plane ticket or get a passport without having to indicate a gender.
“It’s nobody’s business, and it’s irrelevant,” said Forsberg, who was recently involved in a court challenge which forced Saskatchewan to allow people of all ages to remove the gender on their birth certificates.
“I wished they just abolished [gender markers] altogether,” she said.
Hickey believes that’s a possibility, but for now, is happy with the X option, because it provides recognition to a marginalized group.
“It’s important that we have that visibility because we’ve been invisible.”